Homepage > YoungAdult > ChristianFiction > cristiano > Promessa estiva Recensioni

Promessa estiva

Summer Promise
Da Robin Jones Gunn
Recensioni: 30 | Valutazione complessiva: Media
Premiato
10
Bene
6
Media
6
Male
4
Terribile
4
As 14-year old Christy leaves her family's Wisconsin farm to spend the summer at her wealthy aunt and uncle's beach home in Newport, she realizes this could be the best season of her life. . Through it all, will Christy keep her promise to her parents not to do anything she'll regret?

Recensioni

data di revisione 04/21/2020
Madge Ayoub

I think it's safe to say that I am not the intended audience for this book.

The best thing about this book is that my edition was written in blue ink!!! I love when authors/publishers take the extra money to do this. My favorite is Cherie Priest's BONESHAKER, published in brown ink.

Christy is a farm girl from Wisconsin who goes to spend the summer with her aunt and uncle in California. They are rich and spoil her rotten. They buy her new wardrobes, get her hair styled, buy her tons of make-up, swimsuits, etc.

At the beginning, Christy is moaning about how unattractive she is. She thinks she's unattractive because she is "too thin" and has blue-green eyes. OH, THE HORROR! *rolls eyes

Even after her extensive make-over from her shallow, materialistic and looks-oriented aunt, she still spends the whole book calling herself ugly, stupid, and clumsy. Self-hate much? I understand she's 14, but it's painful to read.

Boys. Christy meets a cute boy on the beach! His name is Todd. He's Christian. Not like Christy is Christian, but a "real Christian" who was "born-again." Even though Christy was born and raised in the church and was baptized as a baby and her parents are strict Christians and she is a "good-girl" that's NOT GOOD ENOUGH. Todd informs her that she's still a sinner and needs to "ask Jesus into her heart" otherwise she is not really Christian, she's not really "saved" - no, she's going to HELL.

And that's the love interest.

I thought he was a lousy love interest. For one thing, I felt like he only really pays attention to Christy when she's asking him about his faith and what it means to be a Christian. He also listens to her and encourages her when she makes noise about being saved herself. Otherwise, he's a big flake. He shows up late for dates, sometimes tells her he'll be at a party and doesn't show, blah blah blah. Not worth all the angst and prettifying that Christy goes through for him, in my opinion.

Also, there's this girl named Tracy who hangs around him all the time and he is constantly driving her to work and etc. etc. Christy is jealous and acts like a brat around Tracy. Tracy seems like a great person, but I understand Christy - it's her first date, first boyfriend/sort-of boyfriend etc. and she's insecure. Unfortunately, she NEVER ASKS WHAT'S GOING ON. I mean, she should straight-up ask Tracy, or Todd (whichever one she's more comfortable with) what's going on. I mean, are you guys together? Just friends? Used to date? I fully expected Gunn to reveal Tracy was Todd's cousin, or something. NOTHING. They never explain why Tracy and Todd are together all the time. Instead, we're supposed to be judging Christy for being too insecure, or not trusting Todd enough, or something. GEEZ. It's her first boyfriend (sort-of boyfriend?)! Give her a break. Todd and Tracy give her a joint gift of A BIBLE for her birthday. o.O I don't even know what to make of that.

Then, there's this other girl named Alissa. She's seventeen and dates a 20-year-old! She's on birth control! (We are supposed to be shocked and appalled to learn she's sexually active, but I give her major props for being safe. Hopefully she uses condoms, too!) She tells Christy that there is no God. You have to enjoy life here on Earth while you've got it, because there is no afterlife. We are supposed to feel extreme pity for this woman because her dad's dead and her mom's an alcoholic. Which is why she's "so messed-up." Whatever. Being on the pill and dating slightly older guys is not "messed-up" in my opinion. There's a scene late in the book where Christy witnesses a fight between Alissa and her boyfriend in which it sounds like Alissa's bf wants sex and is having a... difficult time with Alissa saying "no." But I want to stress that Alissa DID say no and the guy leaves in a huff. I don't know what Gunn is trying to say with that. Alissa can be redeemed because she refused to give in to this guy's demands for sex? Or is she saying "loose" women like Alissa end up in dangerous situations where guys might pressure them to have sex and they might give in/get raped? This last one is the kind of bullshit victim-blaming that I HATE. GRRRRRR. Hopefully it's the former and not the latter.

There's one hilarious scene that made me laugh out loud. Christy gets invited to a beach party and she keeps asking people for Coke (because, of course, she doesn't drink beer), and everyone she asks thinks she's looking for COCAINE. This was hilarious to me and I laughed out loud when picturing this little innocent Christian girl asking random guys if they have coke. :)

Oh, yeah, the anti-drug message in this book. A character in the book who will remain anonymous smokes pot and dies. That's right, he DIES. From smoking pot. How, you ask? Well, he decides to surf stoned and this results in him drowning, or bashing his head on some rocks or something. Gunn's anti-drug message was a little...forceful in my opinion. The most hilarious part (to me) was when Todd uses his funeral as a platform to try and turn everyone to Jesus. Seriously. His eulogy is basically slamming his dead friend for not accepting Jesus into his heart and then begging everyone, while crying, to please accept Jesus into their hearts before it's too late. (He doesn't scream, "YOU'RE ALL GOING TO HELL!" but he might as well have.) o.O Very uncomfortable for everyone involved.

In short, I have read Gunn's Gardenias for Breakfast and liked that it was a little more subtle with the Christianity. This one is very forceful and brutal with it's "BE A CHRISTIAN OR BURN IN HELL" message, and I didn't appreciate it. Especially since the book was blatantly saying, "Even though you think you're Christian, you're not really. You're not really Christian until you're MY KIND OF CHRISTIAN. Even Christians who aren't born-again are going to hell." This is very depressing and isolating and self-defeating. I can't understand why Christians insist on dividing each other so much. When I was young, I was shocked to learn about all the animosity between Catholics and Protestants. You'd think people would have some sense of reality, but I guess not.

Christy, the main character, was also unlikeable. Whiny, self-hating, manipulative, insecure, bratlike (throwing temper tantrums a few times), and judging other females and hating on them just because they are "prettier than her". Fail.

P.S. The Dieting. Christy's image obsessed aunt is always a.) lecturing Christy about how much fat is in food, b.) urging her to eat salad, c.) urging her to eat less, d.) shaming her for ordering chocolate cake in a restaurant. If Christy lived with this woman full-time she would end up either a.) morbidly obese or b.) anorexic. She's already hiding food from her aunt, sneaking food when she thinks her aunt can't see her, and eating even when she's not hungry to spite her aunt. Horrible, horrible child-care on the aunt's part. Way to screw up Christy's eating habits and self-image, Aunt Marti.
data di revisione 04/21/2020
Segalman Arocha

this book is awesome i gave my life to christ before i even finished the story. two of my friends did too. its amazing.
data di revisione 04/21/2020
McNair Gadomski

I finished Summer Promise. In short, it was all so shallow it was bad. Now here is the long version.

Christy makes me sick. Her shallow, stereotyped, self conscious crybaby attitude and her mood swings. Literally bleh. She is the most general boring girl contemporary character ever. She struggled with her self image and yet not really the way a girl who actually struggled with it does. The author touched on most topics that girls struggle with, but just touched on them. That's all. Christy felt like a bag of problems and emotions with no backbone. And her "amazing" turn to Christ at the end was a little dull. Like maybe it was forced so that the rest of the series she would be a Christian.
Sorry. I don't mean to bash your guys' fav character, but so far the only thing she's done for me is make me sick.
So did Todd and his "drop dead gorgeousness." *eyeroll* the line where the second day she meets him she says she "realizes she felt for him something that was more than a crush" I snorted SO LOUD the people around me stopped talking for a moment. He seemed so shallow! My heart is crying out for someone who actually has a backbone. The whole deal with Shawn was so predictable. And the way he led Christy on, making her think that he was taking her to the concert, and then all those other folks in the van. And then when he took her to Disneyland totally leading her on. It was horrid. He is an awful character. If he wasn't hiding the fact that her aunt had funded the escapade then he would have mentioned it earlier, like when she said that she appreciated him buying all those things for her. *eyeroll* I think that was a mistake on the authors part maybe? The way that there were places he should have told her and he didn't. Either he is a jerk, or the author didn't do a very good job.

There were two things that I liked in the book, that I could relax and actually enjoy reading. The Disneyland trip (beside the above mentioned) and when Tracy came in. She felt like the only person in the whole book that I could trust. She was sweet and honest and forgiving. I just didn't know where she stood with Todd, which I blame on Todd. Note, (just my personal opinion, I'm not pushing this on any of you guys) you can't be such close friends with a guy ESPECIALLY a Christian guy-girl relationship without any further attractions. Anyway.

And Christy's aunt and uncle killed me. Literally. Her aunt, so shallow. Her uncle, no backbone. At all. A floppy jellyfish that bent to whatever Marti said.

I can't believe how badly I sound like a hater. I am not. I just was so disappointed with this book. I still got the next to in the volume that I'm reading, so we'll see if she gets any better. Right now. Bleh.
data di revisione 04/21/2020
Ewan Volinsky

I've seen countless reviews complaining about how whiny Christy is and how she's a brat . Whiny she may be and at times a brat yes I agree but guess what this is an accurate picture of a teenager . She's awkward , insecure , doesn't really know how to act around people , and may I remind you that she's ONLY FOURTEEN !

Good grief when I was fourteen I was a lot worse ,and let me just say if you were such an angel and never had a single thing to apologize for , well good for you sweetie I'm happy for you .

The other point people make is that whenever Christy meets someone that's not a Christian they ALWAYS have a terrible problem with something ,while the characters that are Christians don't . I can see the point in this truly I can . I know so many Christians that have had problems with things that are sinful or mental health issues . Becoming a Christian doesn't make you perfect all of your problems don't just go away. While I do think her Christian characters could use a few problems . I think she kind of uses the problems of the ( non Christian) characters as something that can help Christy talk to them and show them the love of God . I don't remember really what happens with said characters but that's just what I assume .

With that being said it was so great to be back reading a book that I read so long ago ! Not everything was as I remembered it , and I won't say that it was perfect but let's be real there isn't one excepting the Bible .
data di revisione 04/21/2020
McFadden Baudi

The first time I heard about the Christy Miller series I was only ten or eleven years old. I had won them in a Focus on the Family reading contest. I barely understood the choices that Christy faced and many of the concepts were a little over my head at the time. But when I reread the first 6 or so books again after turning 15, they made a big impact on me. I love Christy. If she were real she would be the closest of my "book" friends- except for maybe Mallory from the Babysitter's Club or Kate O'Connell from the Northwoods Series. She is so sweet and when she doesn't understand something she sits and listens rather than reacting.

I remember my copy of the book, Summer Promise, it looked like an adult romance novel- not at all like the nice updated versions. I learned about drugs for the first time. Not up to this point can I recall hearing the expression "stoned". The Guess teddy-bear t-shirt she wears to the party- I had one of those. I can relate to the way Christy picks out her clothes- underdressed for one event, overdressed for the next. I am rereading this book for I would say fourth or fifth time. Christy's innocences and the simplicity of the story are what I love about Robin Jones Gunn. As I reread the chapter Questions and Answers, I am a lot more emotional about Shawn's funeral. I barely knew Jared Nagel (he was a Christian- praise God!) when he died at age 18 or 19. The youngest person's funeral I have ever attended. Todd is an amazing and to use Doug's word "awesome" young man. Every girl needs a Todd (or Gilbert if you are an Anne of Green Gables fan)!!!

I grew up in California so I knew about many of the places in this book. Especially when they go to San Francisco. Makes you want some Rice-a-Roni. When I go to San Francisco again I am going to find that music box and an Alcatraz sweatshirt for my husband.

Here is one of my favorite quotes from the book...Christy is responding to her Uncle Bob about being true to herself.
"I'm not sure I want to live on the edge like that. I mean, what about God? Where does He fit in? Does He just let me go my merry way, and if I don't happen to 'pull myself in' in time, then splat splat, that's that, too bad Christy?"
data di revisione 04/21/2020
Copland Fupocyupanqui

I first read this book a little over a year ago and now I'm coming back to it and reading it again - partly because I am desperate to finish my 2016 Reading Challenge and I can finish three of these books in a day, and partly because I just love it so much.

This book is super sweet. Part of what I love about it so much is the main character, Christy Miller, and her thoughts and feelings are so relateable. I mean sure I can't really relate to going to parties like the one Christy went to, but her thoughts about Todd and friendship and things like that I can definitely empathize with.

I think it's also super fun to have read all the way up to Christy and Todd: The College Years and then go back to the very first book. A little remark or scene like the green-bean bathing suit makes you grin as you think about the scene in later books where Christy learned that THAT was actually the first time he saw her. ;)

The only thing is Christy is technically going out on what she considers a "date" when she is 14 which is something I would never do but you know yolo Christy do what you want your family has your own standards. xD

Since this book deals with more serious issues I wouldn't recommend these books to, I don't know, 8-year-olds but any mature 11-year-olds and up would be a good age-range.

5 stars out of 5. Love it!! :D
data di revisione 04/21/2020
Eisenberg Plunk

I've heard so much about this series and I finally read the first book! I LOVED how Christy grew spiritually throughout the book, the beach setting, the outfit descriptions, and the Disneyland scene. I didn't like that teenagers so young and far away from marriage kissed. I liked seeing how the different characters reacted to an unexpected death. Warning: There are some teen partying scenes and mature themes. That's why I didn't read it until now.
data di revisione 04/21/2020
Econah Gurley

This was a great Christian teen book. After making a promise to her parents not to do anything she will regret, 14 yr. old Christy goes to stay at her aunt and uncles at the coast of California. Here she learns, as her aunt tries to change her and make her into a fashionable girl, that getting everything you want can't bring you happiness.
She meets a girl named Alissa and really wants to be like her, not knowing how hard Alissa's life is.
Then she meets handsome surfer Todd Spencer. She gets to be friends with him and his friend group. They are all Christians but Christy is not. She thought she was, but she hadn't trusted in Jesus as her savior. Todd helps her understand what it is to be a Christian.
After bad influences, tragedy, and help and prayers of friends, Christy finally makes a life changing decision which is definitely something she will not regret!
data di revisione 04/21/2020
Peatroy Frederic

I first read this series when I was 12 years old. I was absolutely in love with Todd and I adored the lessons that I learned in this book. I am now seventeen and I still am such a huge fan of Christy Miller. The first book, this book, is my least favorite book in the series but I still enjoy it. I just have trouble getting through it because Christy is such a whiny little baby!! I am not an emotional person and I have trouble trying to be patient with Christy because all she does it cry... She does mature later on though and love watching her grow!! If you're a Christian lady and want to grow spiritually while enjoying a cute romantic series, I suggest you pick up Christy Miller!! :)
data di revisione 04/21/2020
Polash Nuber

***The following review may contain slight spoilers. You have been warned.***

Promessa estiva is the first book in the Christy Miller series. This is a book series aimed at young Christian girls. I think I would have liked this one better back when I was really big into Melody Carlson's True Colors series. I thought that this was at least worth checking out because I read Beverly Lewis' Holly's Heart series a while back and enjoyed it. Christy Miller seemed similar.

I'd probably actually give this a 2.5, but it really was just "okay." There were some things that I liked, but also things that I didn't.

COSA MI È PIACIUTO:

The text is blue!

Main character (Christy) is mostly realistic. She's not perfect, she's naive at times, she throws temper tantrums. Definitely no Mary Sue.

Good message overall.

Enjoyed Christy's uncle.

Dealt with REAL issues (drugs, boys, friendship, death, religion).

Great setting (the beach!).


COSA NON MI PIACE

I felt that Christy was mostly realistic except for a few parts which seemed forced. Usually these parts were the ones that dealt with religion or salvation.

Christy's aunt really got on my nerves.

Didn't care for the love interest at all.

The Christian singer at the concert got on my nerves.

The book was "too preachy" at times.



I would recommend this one for young girls discovering their faith who don't mind books that are a bit too preachy. I just don't tend to enjoy books (Christian or non-Christian) that makes me feel like I'm being preached to.

I have the other two books in the series. I *may* read them just so I can give the series a fair chance, but we'll see.


data di revisione 04/21/2020
Kettie Cowling

Scopri altre recensioni su Books to the Sky.

(I received this book free of charge in exchange for an honest review.)

I honestly couldn't finish this book. I had no idea this was going to be religious.

The entire time I was reading the book I felt like I was being preached at. There was a part where Todd, Christy's love interest, made it seem like if you weren't Christian then you weren't worthy.

I strongly disliked her Aunt Marti. From the beginning she was trying to change everything about Christy; what she ate, what she wore and how she acted. I did like her Uncle Bob though. He told her to be herself and that was good enough.

Note: This book was originally published in 1988, it was republished this year for the Kindle.
data di revisione 04/21/2020
Shantha Pelzel

I read this whole series when I was about 13 and I really liked it. Probably would have given it 5 stars.

I just re-read this first book today because I was curious to see if it was as good the second time around. I'll be honest... 2 1/2 stars is the most I would give it. Perhaps it's because I have different taste in books now. Perhaps it's because I'm ten years older than the main character. Or perhaps I was just too young when I read it the first time to realize that it really wasn't that great of a book. Whatever the case, it's definitely not as good as I used to think it was.
data di revisione 04/21/2020
Petromilli Maquis

Robin Jones Gunn deals with some authentic teen issues while keeping with a Christian world view. I enjoyed this fast little read very much, and look forward to reading more from this author.
data di revisione 04/21/2020
Tamar Rogugbakaa

Robin Jones Gunn posted this week on a social media site that during a radio interview she was introduced as Christy Miller. I can see why. The character she created is so realistic that I, as a non-fiction aficionado, enjoyed this book greatly.

This is a Christian book, and I normally have a bias against books that weave the "plan of salvation" into the story line, but aside from that I want to read the rest of this series, and I'm not even the target age range!

I believe this was ooriginally published in the mid 90s, it's a bit dated in the fact the teenagers have no cell phones! I thought different times how crazy it was none of them texted! What a difference fifteen years makes!

The book doesn't shy away from difficult topics. Drinking. Drugs. Death. Sexually active friends. An alcoholic mother of a friend. These might make this book not a great choice for a tween, but unfortunately this is the world in which teens live, so tackling these topics in a book would likely be a great help to some girls.

Christy is from Wisconsin, but living with her aunt and uncle for the summer. She makes new friends who are different from those she knows back home. She takes risks in wardrobe and changes her hair, starts wearing make up and she falls for a guy who takes her to Disneyland for her birthday, but then at the end of the day things aren't quite the way she thought they were. . .

The biggest thing I disliked about this book is it's part of a series, and of course, when the end comes, you're left wondering what is going to happen next. But, I solved that by reading reviews online of book two in the series. I do want to finish reading this series at some point!

FTC disclaimer: I received a digital download of this book for review purposes. The opinions are my own.



data di revisione 04/21/2020
Circosta Cranmore

I received an electronic copy of this book from Librarything's Early Review program in exchange for an honest review.

Book Summary from Amazon:

"As 14-year-old Christy leaves her family's Wisconisn farm to spend the summer at her wealthy aunt and uncle's beach home in Newport, she realizes this could be the best season of her life. She's full of hope that surfer Todd will like her; the beach crowd will accept her; and she can become like her gorgeous new friend, Alissa.

But the summer doesn't unfold as Christy hoped; she discovers this season also holds heartache. Todd wavers between Christy and another girl; 16-year-old Shawn dies in a drug-related surfing accident-and the police want to know how Christy was involved; Alissa discloses that her sophistication hides a painful past.

Through it all, will Christy keep her promise to her parents not to do anything she'll regret? Or will she do anything to get Todd, to be accepted, to force her summer to give her everything it promised?"


What I liked about this book: The message. Gunn's story provides a positive message for teens. Even as an adult Christian I found passages that spoke to me. Though the book touches on several serious issues, it has a light tone. It doesn't weigh the reader down.

What I didn't like about the book: The writing was all over the place. Some passages were beautifully written with great depth. Other passages were rather flat. Sometimes, I wasn't sure if the writer knew where she was going with the story. Christy is a mostly likable character, but she seems rather immature for her age.

The series has great potential and I'm interested to see where she goes with the series.
data di revisione 04/21/2020
Snider Hagemann

It seems a fairly common question to ask someone what book changed their life. Whenever I hear this, I immediately go to the Christy Miller series (and then feel like a bad English major because it's far from literature). But it's the truth. It's certainly not everyone's cup of tea, but for young teen girls confused about God and life as they fully transition into adolescence, it's perfect. It shows that there is more to romance than what is currently marketed to teens and that taking it slow has its rewards. It's certainly not as brutally honest as Becoming Me and the rest of the Diary of a Teenage Girl series by Carlson, but they make a nice pairing.

As for unrealistic expectations about how being good=getting the perfect guy... I'm going on 27 and still waiting on my Todd but don't seem too damaged by these novels. The broader theme of waiting on God's timing is one that remains applicable throughout our lives, not just when we're super young. And yes, the Bible does tell us that we will be rewarded for our faithfulness. Those rewards don't necessarily manifest in a husband, but I'm not sure that's the message this book is sending.
data di revisione 04/21/2020
Dorsman Malpica

I finally got the chance to read my first Christy Miller book, after hearing so many great things about the series. Summer Promise is definitely an enjoyable read! Christy's story drew me in from the start and I finished it in one sitting.

Christy is such a sweet and innocent character that I think a lot of younger girls can relate to. She reminded me a lot of my younger self. Occasionally I thought some of her actions made her appear younger than a fourteen-year-old girl, and that sort of drew me out of the story. However, the majority of Christy's actions was realistic.

Summer Promise deals with real issues that a lot of teens face today. Christy's journey to become a true Christian is believable, and not preachy or forced at any point. The questions she asks about her faith are true concerns that many teens have. I wish I had read this when I was a little younger, but I still loved it and I'm looking forward to reading the next book.

This is a very cute and sweet book that I think a lot of younger girls will love. I recommend it to middle school/high school girls!

I received a copy of this book from Blogging for Books in exchange for my honest review.
data di revisione 04/21/2020
Weyermann Delallo

Targeted toward tweens to young teens, this well written story tackles the challenges of being a teenager and kicks it up a notch by focusing on the Christian teen. Christy is the average teen who only wants to be accepted and ends up in some very uncomfortable and unsafe situations. She lives on a farm, goes to church every Sunday, and is the all around "good" girl. She is soon to be 15 and not only wants friends, but wants a summer romance while she stays with her Aunt and Uncle. Her being boy crazy has an influence on how she looks at things and at times, her attitude is down-right annoying.

This book focuses heavily on peer pressure and how it can change one's life by making wrong decisions. After a particularly disturbing incident that happens to one of Christy's friends, there comes to light a very strong salvation message making this a wonderful tool to give to the teen that is beginning to question things about God.

All in all, this is a great book to give to any girl who struggles with peer pressure!!
data di revisione 04/21/2020
Kale Boinotre

There were elements of this book that I really enjoyed and thought were totally appropriate and applicable in a young girl's life today, issues that she would be hungering to know more about and I liked how the author dealt with these heavy topics. What I didn't care for was how young Christy was to be obsessed over some boy that she had only just met, I felt like she was a little too immature to try juggling a boyfriend. While this book had some good points I wasn't too impressed with the quality of the material or characters.

* Tratto dal mio blog di recensioni di libri: http://reviewsatmse.blogspot.com/2008...
data di revisione 04/21/2020
Birchard Jashinal

Young teenager Christy spends the summer in California with her rich and worldly aunt and uncle. Christy faces challenges in her friendships and self-image and questions what is important in this life. I've wanted to read these books since being impressed with other titles by Robin Jones Gunn. I thought this was a very realistic look at some issues facing teenagers in the 90's (its a tad bit dated! :-)) and maybe even a little too realistic. I would recommend it for teenagers on the mature side. Looking forward to Book 2!
data di revisione 04/21/2020
Rosalinda Spitznogle

I was browsing through my old bookshelf looking for a specific book when I came across this one. I remember reading this serires a long time ago, wehn I was about 9 or 10 and I really enjoyed it. Other than it being a Christian book, I didn't remember anything else from it as it's been about 9 years since I've read it. It's a bit preachy, but it was a cute story despite that.
data di revisione 04/21/2020
Fritzsche Yoss

Another fantastic book by Robin Jones Gunn. The settings for her books are always just right for her storys.
data di revisione 04/21/2020
Bolanger Matheis

I originally read the Christy Miller series as a teenager. I never got to the "college years" and such but I wanted to restart my book journey which meant re-reading the series.
I think Christy was a fairly realistic teenager. She struggled with her self esteem and trying to find herself in a big world. She got a little boy crazy. She had her streaks of rebellion and at times maybe was too whiny. It is the growth she begins to show that really makes the series what it is.

OFFICIAL RATING: A+ - This book checked all the boxes.

AUTHOR'S STYLE: 10/10 - Her style is easy to read and get invested in. It makes for a quick read and flows well.

AUTHOR'S CHARACTERS: 10/10 - The characters are not always endearing or perfect, but they're very realistic to form and it is easy to see their flaws and strengths. Christy, Todd, Doug and the likes are very relatable. Characters like Aunt Marti and Shawn are reminders what life looks like when you're living without God guiding your boat.

THE PLOT ITSELF: 10/10 - I love how she drew together the theme of "finding yourself" and how people can do it the right and the wrong ways. In this life many people are going to tell you to go wherever your arrow takes you, but what if your arrow doesn't follow the path God is giving you? What if you don't get to "Hawaii"? In the world finding yourself is finding a sense of fashion, a boyfriend to complete you, having the perfect figure. In God's eyes, finding yourself is turning to Him and following His path for you. Christy certainly said it right, when we try to run the boat, we mess things up! I feel like every story line showed the perks, but also the consequences, of occasionally taking things into your own hands. It may seem great at first, but eventually you realize that empty part of you cannot be found "in the mall".

STRONG SUBPLOTS TO DISCUSS:
"VANITY" - Christy is very insecure about her appearance at the start of the book, and her Aunt helps build a flaw into Christy. Christy suddenly wanted all these different outfits, all these looks as it somehow made her more popular or more like Alissa. However, none of these things really took away the eating insecurity inside her, or filled her emptiness. It is a reminder material things and appearances do not define people and do not fill you.
"JEALOUSY" - Christy likes Todd and spends quite a bit of the story jealous of Tracy and Todd's close relationship. However, Christy toward the end of the story realizes how wrong it is of her to be hurtful to Tracy due to this, after Tracy has spent so much time being so kind to her and even helps Todd with her birthday gift. It is a reminder jealousy is in fact an ugly emotion.
"ACCEPTING GOD" - I do love how this book again draws a difference between "faith" and "religion." Of course Christy is 'religious', she was baptized and goes to church every Sunday. Todd and his friends kept asking her to "accept God" though, although most of the book she struggled with feeling she didn't need that as she already had God. However, she realizes accepting faith is a lot more than church on Sunday, it is as Todd put it, getting into the boat and letting God captain the ship. Asking Him into your heart and your every day life.

How "original" the story comes across - 6/10 - This story isn't exactly a "new" idea but it is done well and done in her voice, so I don't have any issues with the "I've read this plot a few times now" feeling.

Overall I do recommend this story to people of any age. Christy can be a reminder of our own insecure teen years, but also a reminder of growth and change that can happen through God. It is a reminder no material thing can take place of the God shaped hole in our hearts, and we need to seek Him every single day.
data di revisione 04/21/2020
La Verne Grochmal

"I'd rather be true to the Lord."

Several years ago I mistakenly read one of the 'forever friends' books out of order [Christy Miller series is the trunk and many other friends have their own series and sub series that read like branches] be sure to do your research and read in the chronological order.

Now I'm rereading them again as to remind myself that while 'adulting' is exhausting sometimes, I'm so thankful to be done and over the teen years in my own life. What I thought made me seem older when I was 14/15 now feels laughable compared to what God really had in store for my life. I'm certain I will always consider RJG's fictitious characters friends because they feel so real to me. I'm eager to keep rereading in preparation to the new series being published in 2019.
data di revisione 04/21/2020
Garth Fetherolf

I can’t remember the last time I read a book in one sitting. Christy is an old childhood friend, and it was good to revisit her even if her bratty wallowing was a bit more obnoxious than when I thought fourteen was so old and mature. I know I’m not the indented audience now, but it was so sweet to meet her again.
data di revisione 04/21/2020
Colin Streitnatter

This book series shaped my teen years. I must have read the series 5 or 6 times all the way through. I could almost quote word for word parts of this book.

I recently heard Robin Jones Gunn on a podcast and decided to read them again. While I’m an adult now, I still connected to Christy’s insecurities and doubt as a teenager.

Loved it all over again.

Lascia una recensione per Promessa estiva